Question:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t Where are your refutations against Christianity? They melt beneath you like snowflakes in the fullness of the summer sun. How poetic. Thanks for that thought. Here are some references for your consideration: The Jesus Puzzle. Did Christianity Begin with a Mythical Christ? Challenging the Existence of an Historical Jesus-, by Earl J. Doherty https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0968601405 "… The epistle to the Hebrews is anonymous. Of those under the names of Peter, James, John and Jude, none today are judged to be authentic. That is, they were not written by those legendary followers of Jesus. These epistles too may originally have been anonymous, or had their original ascriptions dropped; new names were added, possibly at the time the epistles were collected and a canon was being formed …"
Hebrews being anonymous hardly invalidates the truths that it contains. I am unaware of any contestation of authenticity of the other writings you list. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text —- The Christ Conspiracy: The Greatest Story Ever Sold-, by Acharaya S http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0932813747 http://www.truthbeknown.com/christcon.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ3.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ4.htm "… In reality, like Jesus, the famous biblical disciples are recorded nowhere in the works of any historian of their time. The only source of the disciples/apostles is in Christian literature, in which the stories of their ‘lives’ are in fact highly apocryphal, allegorical and, therefore, inadequate as ‘history’ or ‘biography’. … The disciple, apostle and saint Peter, ‘the Rock’ to whom so much of the Christian religion is entrusted, is easily revealed to be a mythological character and old motif …"
Wrong..the rock that Jesus spoke of was self referential. Peter was not the rock upon which the church was to be built. The Book Your Church Doesn’t Want You to Read, by Tim C. Leedom (Editor) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0939040158 "Consider this book as a kind of consumer protection guide to religion, a big step forward toward religious literacy.
I’m sure it is goot at showing religion to be a bunch of hooey, which is exactly what I believe. Readers will explore myths, origins, fundamentalism, television ministries, the identical stories of Stellar/Pagan/ Christian beliefs, unfounded doctrines, child abuse, the Year 2000, and women’s rights. It’s entertaining and readable, with a sense of humor reflecting the absurdities of fundamental religion — while being inoffensive."
Religion is more than just absurd..it is dangerous. — Who Wrote the New Testament? The Making of Christian Myth, by Burton L. Mack http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060655186 "I am very selective about books I choose to buy and display; I prefer those that can really make a difference or illustrate a method or a new perspective. Mack’s book does an excellent job of debunking and explaining the Christian myth and deserves widespread reading. If superstition and myth can be recognized and understood as such, society will be strengthened and enriched. It is like the Emperor’s New Clothes – someone has pointed at the Emperor and written an accessible and enlightening book on the subject."
And you chose not to quote some of the more persuaisive points in it. May I remind you that this is an area for discussion, not advertisment of literature. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text —- One Jesus, Many Christs : How Jesus Inspired Not One True Christianity, but Many : The Truth About Christian Origins, by Gregory J. Riley http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060667990 "Riley argues that Jesus had a lot in common with familiar figures like Hercules and Achilles. The classical heroes claimed a mix of divine-human parentage, usually with a virgin human mother and a god for a father; they possessed some remarkable or even miraculous skill; they had divine enemies and were hated by powerful humans; they died, often young and violently, as martyrs for a principle; and their deaths powerfully transformed other people’s lives through emulation. Jesus fits the bill perfectly, Riley argues, because the Gospel writers had obtained a classical education, which meant that they were thoroughly steeped in heroic lore.
You speak of other religions. I assure you I can show you how Jesus taught something totally new on this planet that never before existed on this planet. Early converts readily embraced Christianity’s message, despite tremendous penalty from a hostile Roman government, because it captured the heroic formula that peasants had heard recited and then memorized.
And you can provide historical evidence of this? There are manuscripts that show this going on? Or is it mere speculation on what might have happened? The second half of the book drives home this point about the source of Christianity’s popularity. Riley demonstrates that it certainly wasn’t doctrine that attracted the masses, since the earliest apostles couldn’t agree on the most basic tenets of the faith.
Care to name some? Dozens of sects arose in different cities, all claiming to be the religion of the risen Christ (though whether he had risen in spirit or body was itself a subject of heated debate). What they could agree on was that Jesus was a hero and that they, as martyrs for the faith, could become heroes themselves.
By your own statement, they also agreed that he had risen. Such faithfulness constituted the religion of Christ into the fourth century, which witnessed the conversion of Constantine and the great creedal controversies."
I have some question of Constantine’s conversion. However, hero worship is hardly a basis for lasting faithfulness. My english teacher was my hero back in grade school. He certainly influenced me for a while, but not for that long. Hero worship comes and goes as do all fads. No, that explenation just doesn’t cut it. — The Case Against Christianity, by Michael Martin http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1566390818 "Logical examination of Christianity by a professional philosopher – This book is logically thorough and destroys Christianity on all important evidential and rational grounds, although I doubt that any whose faith has been sufficient thus far will be led to deconvert. It will however expose them to the fact that they have no rational grounds for their belief."
Believing in an all powerful, all knowing, independent, and omnipresent God could never be considered a rational act. The idea of "rational" is tied to this world(universe) and this existance and cannot be a standard by which God can be measured. — Pagan and Christian Creeds: Their Origin and Meaning, by Edward Carpenter, preface by Paul Tice http://shop.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/isbnInquiry.asp?isbn=158509… " A very level-headed approach, doesn’t go after Christianity to attack it, merely compares and contrasts it with the Pagan world and explores similarities and hidden meanings still present in the religion today. Incredible implications."
I can show you that all other religions are a dead end. Only Christianity ever had or ever will have a chance at being right. — Why Christianity Must Change or Die : A Bishop Speaks to Believers in Exile, by John Shelby Spong, Richard Dominick http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675365 "Spong refers to himself as a believer in exile. He believes the world into which Christianity was born was limited and provincial, particularly when viewed from the perspective of the progress in knowledge and technology made over the past two millennia. This makes any ideas or beliefs formulated in 1st-century Judea totally inadequate to our progressive minds and lives today. So Spong is in exile until Christianity is re-formed to discard all of the outdated and, according to Spong, false tenets of Christianity."
Christ is the same yesterday, today, and tomorrow. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text —- Liberating the Gospels : Reading the Bible With Jewish Eyes : Freeing Jesus from 2,000 Years of Misunderstanding, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675578 "The Bible has, of course, been read with Jewish eyes from the moment it was written: it is a Jewish book. But Liberating the Gospels is a Christian book; and Spong, bishop of the Episcopal diocese of Newark, New Jersey, urges his Christian audience to remember that the book they call the New Testament was written almost entirely by Jewish authors for an audience that was initially almost entirely Jewish, an audience to whom it would not have occurred to think of the Bible (the ‘Law’ and the ‘Prophets’ ) as anything but Jewish…"
Acts 20:21 Testifying both to the Jews, and also to the Greeks, repentance toward God, and faith toward our Lord Jesus Christ. Romans 1:16 For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek. Romans 2:10 But glory, honour, and peace, to every man that worketh good, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile: Romans 2:11 For there is no respect of persons with God. – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text —- Resurrection : Myth or Reality? : A Bishop’s Search for the Origins of Christianity, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060674296 The Episcopal bishop of Newark, New Jersey, offers a
… read more »
Response:
Come on Dan. Surely you know that I can find just as many books, written by just-as-competent men, about how the resurrection is as historical as the attack on Pearl Harbor. Do you have anything else?
I submit you cannot find competent unbiased non-christian-dependent men interested in truth who can demonstrate the resurrection was true. The attack on Pearl Harbor? Competent men interested in truth do not dispute the attack on Pearl Harbor. Your historical claim, does that have to do with the truth, fiction, or myth? Dan Fake, FREELOVER #1, who cares deeply about truth, freedom, and maxing out this one and only experience we all know and share on this earth, at this time, in this life. FREELOVER? Freethinking Realist Exploring Expressive Liberty, Openness, Verity, Enlightenment, & Rationality (also, pro-love, free from state and church authorities) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Donovan Yarrido wrote … Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t Where are your refutations against Christianity? They melt beneath you like snowflakes in the fullness of the summer sun. How poetic. Thanks for that thought. Here are some references for your consideration: The Jesus Puzzle. Did Christianity Begin with a Mythical Christ? Challenging the Existence of an Historical Jesus-, by Earl J. Doherty https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0968601405 "… The epistle to the Hebrews is anonymous. Of those under the names of Peter, James, John and Jude, none today are judged to be authentic. That is, they were not written by those legendary followers of Jesus. These epistles too may originally have been anonymous, or had their original ascriptions dropped; new names were added, possibly at the time the epistles were collected and a canon was being formed …" — The Christ Conspiracy: The Greatest Story Ever Sold-, by Acharaya S http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0932813747 http://www.truthbeknown.com/christcon.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ3.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ4.htm "… In reality, like Jesus, the famous biblical disciples are recorded nowhere in the works of any historian of their time. The only source of the disciples/apostles is in Christian literature, in which the stories of their ‘lives’ are in fact highly apocryphal, allegorical and, therefore, inadequate as ‘history’ or ‘biography’. … The disciple, apostle and saint Peter, ‘the Rock’ to whom so much of the Christian religion is entrusted, is easily revealed to be a mythological character and old motif …" The Book Your Church Doesn’t Want You to Read, by Tim C. Leedom (Editor) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0939040158 "Consider this book as a kind of consumer protection guide to religion, a big step forward toward religious literacy. Readers will explore myths, origins, fundamentalism, television ministries, the identical stories of Stellar/Pagan/ Christian beliefs, unfounded doctrines, child abuse, the Year 2000, and women’s rights. It’s entertaining and readable, with a sense of humor reflecting the absurdities of fundamental religion — while being inoffensive." — Who Wrote the New Testament? The Making of Christian Myth, by Burton L. Mack http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060655186 "I am very selective about books I choose to buy and display; I prefer those that can really make a difference or illustrate a method or a new perspective. Mack’s book does an excellent job of debunking and explaining the Christian myth and deserves widespread reading. If superstition and myth can be recognized and understood as such, society will be strengthened and enriched. It is like the Emperor’s New Clothes – someone has pointed at the Emperor and written an accessible and enlightening book on the subject." — One Jesus, Many Christs : How Jesus Inspired Not One True Christianity, but Many : The Truth About Christian Origins, by Gregory J. Riley http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060667990 "Riley argues that Jesus had a lot in common with familiar figures like Hercules and Achilles. The classical heroes claimed a mix of divine-human parentage, usually with a virgin human mother and a god for a father; they possessed some remarkable or even miraculous skill; they had divine enemies and were hated by powerful humans; they died, often young and violently, as martyrs for a principle; and their deaths powerfully transformed other people’s lives through emulation. Jesus fits the bill perfectly, Riley argues, because the Gospel writers had obtained a classical education, which meant that they were thoroughly steeped in heroic lore. Early converts readily embraced Christianity’s message, despite tremendous penalty from a hostile Roman government, because it captured the heroic formula that peasants had heard recited and then memorized. The second half of the book drives home this point about the source of Christianity’s popularity. Riley demonstrates that it certainly wasn’t doctrine that attracted the masses, since the earliest apostles couldn’t agree on the most basic tenets of the faith. Dozens of sects arose in different cities, all claiming to be the religion of the risen Christ (though whether he had risen in spirit or body was itself a subject of heated debate). What they could agree on was that Jesus was a hero and that they, as martyrs for the faith, could become heroes themselves. Such faithfulness constituted the religion of Christ into the fourth century, which witnessed the conversion of Constantine and the great creedal controversies." — The Case Against Christianity, by Michael Martin http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1566390818 "Logical examination of Christianity by a professional philosopher – This book is logically thorough and destroys Christianity on all important evidential and rational grounds, although I doubt that any whose faith has been sufficient thus far will be led to deconvert. It will however expose them to the fact that they have no rational grounds for their belief." — Pagan and Christian Creeds: Their Origin and Meaning, by Edward Carpenter, preface by Paul Tice http://shop.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/isbnInquiry.asp?isbn=158509… " A very level-headed approach, doesn’t go after Christianity to attack it, merely compares and contrasts it with the Pagan world and explores similarities and hidden meanings still present in the religion today. Incredible implications." — Why Christianity Must Change or Die : A Bishop Speaks to Believers in Exile, by John Shelby Spong, Richard Dominick http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675365 "Spong refers to himself as a believer in exile. He believes the world into which Christianity was born was limited and provincial, particularly when viewed from the perspective of the progress in knowledge and technology made over the past two millennia. This makes any ideas or beliefs formulated in 1st-century Judea totally inadequate to our progressive minds and lives today. So Spong is in exile until Christianity is re-formed to discard all of the outdated and, according to Spong, false tenets of Christianity." — Liberating the Gospels : Reading the Bible With Jewish Eyes : Freeing Jesus from 2,000 Years of Misunderstanding, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675578 "The Bible has, of course, been read with Jewish eyes from the moment it was written: it is a Jewish book. But Liberating the Gospels is a Christian book; and Spong, bishop of the Episcopal diocese of Newark, New Jersey, urges his Christian audience to remember that the book they call the New Testament was written almost entirely by Jewish authors for an audience that was initially almost entirely Jewish, an audience to whom it would not have occurred to think of the Bible (the ‘Law’ and the ‘Prophets’ ) as anything but Jewish…" — Resurrection : Myth or Reality? : A Bishop’s Search for the Origins of Christianity, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060674296 The Episcopal bishop of Newark, New Jersey, offers a controversial view of the key element in Christianity–the resurrection of Jesus. Spong suggests that Christians have forgotten that the New Testament frequently makes use of Midrash, a genre in which different biblical motifs are interwoven in order to speak of things that transcend human categories. Thus the story of Joshua’s parting of the sea means that he was a second Moses, and the opening of the heavens at Jesus’ baptism tells us that Jesus is the true Moses. Spong argues that since Jesus’ resurrection is divine, it is beyond the realm of history, and the stories surrounding it are Midrash. The question we need to ask, then, is not whether these stories are literally true, but what experience they describe." — Born of a Woman : A Bishop Rethinks the Birth of Jesus, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675233 "John Shelby Spong, best-selling author and Episcopal bishop of Newark, NJ, challenges the doctrine of the virgin birth, tracing its development in the early Christian church and revealing its legacy in our contemporary attitudes toward women and female
… read more »
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – So, christianity and every other faith has flaws. Go figure. Humans created ‘em so how unflawed could they be? The religion is flawed. Now, if god had created any of these faiths, don’t yuh think, just maybe, god could’ve come up with an unflawed faith? Maybe? Don’t yuh think, being omnipotent and all, the all-seeing, all-knowing, master of the universe, THE CREATOR of it all, could’ve come close to an unflawed faith, or no god forbid, could’ve actually created an unflawed faith? DO YOU LISTEN TO ANYTHING WE ACTUALLY SAY?
Sure, typing in all caps really helps. (-: The faith is great, the religion we build on top of it is flawed. Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws. IDIOT
Where have I heard that before? Oh well, you seem stuck in a rut. Try to offer something other than ad hominems and you will definitely have a better chance at raising my receptivity to your points of view. Thanks for your consideration. Dan Fake, FREELOVER #1, who cares deeply about truth, freedom, and maxing out this one and only experience we all know and share on this earth, at this time, in this life. FREELOVER? Freethinking Realist Exploring Expressive Liberty, Openness, Verity, Enlightenment, & Rationality (also, pro-love, free from state and church authorities) – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -Mike
Response:
Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t
Where are your refutations against Christianity? They melt beneath you like snowflakes in the fulness of the summer sun.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws. IDIOT Mike Judge not lest ye be judged yourself. Isn’t it funny how people, when they can’t think of something intelligent to say, or an actuall argument for a debate, turn so quickly to meaningless insults? A few questions for Mike: Did calling him an IDIOT in anyway prove, or even argue that his beliefs were wrong and yours were right?
I called him an idiot because I am annoyed at having to respond to pretty much the same post over and over… How did calling him an IDIOT have anything to do with the actual topic?
No If you are christian, was it not your God that said Judge not?
I didnt judge him, I called him an idiot. If you are not christian, who are you to judge others beliefs?
I am. Why must you resort to belittling people in a debate, can you not find a suffician arguement?
Can he stop posting the same thing in different guises over and over again? Did it ever occur to you, that you may be exactly what you are calling others?
Never
Mike
Response:
Come on Dan. Surely you know that I can find just as many books, written by just-as-competent men, about how the resurrection is as historical as the attack on Pearl Harbor. Do you have anything else? Donovan
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t Where are your refutations against Christianity? They melt beneath you like snowflakes in the fullness of the summer sun. How poetic. Thanks for that thought. Here are some references for your consideration: The Jesus Puzzle. Did Christianity Begin with a Mythical Christ? Challenging the Existence of an Historical Jesus-, by Earl J. Doherty https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0968601405 "… The epistle to the Hebrews is anonymous. Of those under the names of Peter, James, John and Jude, none today are judged to be authentic. That is, they were not written by those legendary followers of Jesus. These epistles too may originally have been anonymous, or had their original ascriptions dropped; new names were added, possibly at the time the epistles were collected and a canon was being formed …" — The Christ Conspiracy: The Greatest Story Ever Sold-, by Acharaya S http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0932813747 http://www.truthbeknown.com/christcon.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ3.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ4.htm "… In reality, like Jesus, the famous biblical disciples are recorded nowhere in the works of any historian of their time. The only source of the disciples/apostles is in Christian literature, in which the stories of their ‘lives’ are in fact highly apocryphal, allegorical and, therefore, inadequate as ‘history’ or ‘biography’. … The disciple, apostle and saint Peter, ‘the Rock’ to whom so much of the Christian religion is entrusted, is easily revealed to be a mythological character and old motif …" The Book Your Church Doesn’t Want You to Read, by Tim C. Leedom (Editor) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0939040158 "Consider this book as a kind of consumer protection guide to religion, a big step forward toward religious literacy. Readers will explore myths, origins, fundamentalism, television ministries, the identical stories of Stellar/Pagan/ Christian beliefs, unfounded doctrines, child abuse, the Year 2000, and women’s rights. It’s entertaining and readable, with a sense of humor reflecting the absurdities of fundamental religion — while being inoffensive." — Who Wrote the New Testament? The Making of Christian Myth, by Burton L. Mack http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060655186 "I am very selective about books I choose to buy and display; I prefer those that can really make a difference or illustrate a method or a new perspective. Mack’s book does an excellent job of debunking and explaining the Christian myth and deserves widespread reading. If superstition and myth can be recognized and understood as such, society will be strengthened and enriched. It is like the Emperor’s New Clothes – someone has pointed at the Emperor and written an accessible and enlightening book on the subject." — One Jesus, Many Christs : How Jesus Inspired Not One True Christianity, but Many : The Truth About Christian Origins, by Gregory J. Riley http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060667990 "Riley argues that Jesus had a lot in common with familiar figures like Hercules and Achilles. The classical heroes claimed a mix of divine-human parentage, usually with a virgin human mother and a god for a father; they possessed some remarkable or even miraculous skill; they had divine enemies and were hated by powerful humans; they died, often young and violently, as martyrs for a principle; and their deaths powerfully transformed other people’s lives through emulation. Jesus fits the bill perfectly, Riley argues, because the Gospel writers had obtained a classical education, which meant that they were thoroughly steeped in heroic lore. Early converts readily embraced Christianity’s message, despite tremendous penalty from a hostile Roman government, because it captured the heroic formula that peasants had heard recited and then memorized. The second half of the book drives home this point about the source of Christianity’s popularity. Riley demonstrates that it certainly wasn’t doctrine that attracted the masses, since the earliest apostles couldn’t agree on the most basic tenets of the faith. Dozens of sects arose in different cities, all claiming to be the religion of the risen Christ (though whether he had risen in spirit or body was itself a subject of heated debate). What they could agree on was that Jesus was a hero and that they, as martyrs for the faith, could become heroes themselves. Such faithfulness constituted the religion of Christ into the fourth century, which witnessed the conversion of Constantine and the great creedal controversies." — The Case Against Christianity, by Michael Martin http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1566390818 "Logical examination of Christianity by a professional philosopher – This book is logically thorough and destroys Christianity on all important evidential and rational grounds, although I doubt that any whose faith has been sufficient thus far will be led to deconvert. It will however expose them to the fact that they have no rational grounds for their belief." — Pagan and Christian Creeds: Their Origin and Meaning, by Edward Carpenter, preface by Paul Tice http://shop.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/isbnInquiry.asp?isbn=158509… " A very level-headed approach, doesn’t go after Christianity to attack it, merely compares and contrasts it with the Pagan world and explores similarities and hidden meanings still present in the religion today. Incredible implications." — Why Christianity Must Change or Die : A Bishop Speaks to Believers in Exile, by John Shelby Spong, Richard Dominick http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675365 "Spong refers to himself as a believer in exile. He believes the world into which Christianity was born was limited and provincial, particularly when viewed from the perspective of the progress in knowledge and technology made over the past two millennia. This makes any ideas or beliefs formulated in 1st-century Judea totally inadequate to our progressive minds and lives today. So Spong is in exile until Christianity is re-formed to discard all of the outdated and, according to Spong, false tenets of Christianity." — Liberating the Gospels : Reading the Bible With Jewish Eyes : Freeing Jesus from 2,000 Years of Misunderstanding, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675578 "The Bible has, of course, been read with Jewish eyes from the moment it was written: it is a Jewish book. But Liberating the Gospels is a Christian book; and Spong, bishop of the Episcopal diocese of Newark, New Jersey, urges his Christian audience to remember that the book they call the New Testament was written almost entirely by Jewish authors for an audience that was initially almost entirely Jewish, an audience to whom it would not have occurred to think of the Bible (the ‘Law’ and the ‘Prophets’ ) as anything but Jewish…" — Resurrection : Myth or Reality? : A Bishop’s Search for the Origins of Christianity, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060674296 The Episcopal bishop of Newark, New Jersey, offers a controversial view of the key element in Christianity–the resurrection of Jesus. Spong suggests that Christians have forgotten that the New Testament frequently makes use of Midrash, a genre in which different biblical motifs are interwoven in order to speak of things that transcend human categories. Thus the story of Joshua’s parting of the sea means that he was a second Moses, and the opening of the heavens at Jesus’ baptism tells us that Jesus is the true Moses. Spong argues that since Jesus’ resurrection is divine, it is beyond the realm of history, and the stories surrounding it are Midrash. The question we need to ask, then, is not whether these stories are literally true, but what experience they describe." — Born of a Woman : A Bishop Rethinks the Birth of Jesus, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675233 "John Shelby Spong, best-selling author and Episcopal bishop of Newark, NJ, challenges the doctrine of the virgin birth, tracing its development in the early Christian church and revealing its legacy in our contemporary attitudes toward women and female sexuality. Synopsis: Now in paperback from the best-selling author of Living in Sin? comes a carefully researched, bold, and persuasive argument that ‘the virgin of a literal Bible, the virgin of annunciation, Bethlehem, and the manger, corrupted by the years of an overlaid male theology, will have to go’." — Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism : A Bishop Rethinks the Meaning of Scripture, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675187 "Now in paperback, the provocative national bestseller that issues a daring call for contemporary understanding of scripture. Outspoken and controversial, Bishop Spong brilliantly reclaims the Bible from the narrow-minded literalism that has been used to justify slavery, ban textbooks, deny the rights of gays and lesbians, subordinate women, and justify war and revenge."
… read more »
Response:
Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws. IDIOT Mike
Judge not lest ye be judged yourself. Isn’t it funny how people, when they can’t think of something intelligent to say, or an actuall argument for a debate, turn so quickly to meaningless insults? A few questions for Mike: Did calling him an IDIOT in anyway prove, or even argue that his beliefs were wrong and yours were right? How did calling him an IDIOT have anything to do with the actual topic? If you are christian, was it not your God that said Judge not? If you are not christian, who are you to judge others beliefs? Why must you resort to belittling people in a debate, can you not find a suffician arguement? Did it ever occur to you, that you may be exactly what you are calling others? — ***Compulsive Destruction*** promote/find bands. contact me to have yours added http://homepages.go.com/~compdest/ Before you buy.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – So, christianity and every other faith has flaws. Go figure. Humans created ‘em so how unflawed could they be? The religion is flawed. Now, if god had created any of these faiths, don’t yuh think, just maybe, god could’ve come up with an unflawed faith? Maybe? Don’t yuh think, being omnipotent and all, the all-seeing, all-knowing, master of the universe, THE CREATOR of it all, could’ve come close to an unflawed faith, or no god forbid, could’ve actually created an unflawed faith? DO YOU LISTEN TO ANYTHING WE ACTUALLY SAY? Sure, typing in all caps really helps. (-: The faith is great, the religion we build on top of it is flawed. Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws. IDIOT Where have I heard that before? Oh well, you seem stuck in a rut. Try to offer something other than ad hominems and you will definitely have a better chance at raising my receptivity to your points of view. Thanks for your consideration.
It is duly noted that you have no answer to my objections and that you do infact have no listening mechanism at all. Is that a FREELOVER principle? Mike
Response:
So, christianity and every other faith has flaws. Go figure. Humans created ‘em so how unflawed could they be?
The religion is flawed. Now, if god had created any of these faiths, don’t yuh think, just maybe, god could’ve come up with an unflawed faith? Maybe? Don’t yuh think, being omnipotent and all, the all-seeing, all-knowing, master of the universe, THE CREATOR of it all, could’ve come close to an unflawed faith, or no god forbid, could’ve actually created an unflawed faith?
DO YOU LISTEN TO ANYTHING WE ACTUALLY SAY? The faith is great, the religion we build on top of it is flawed. Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws.
IDIOT Mike
Response:
Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t Where are your refutations against Christianity? They melt beneath you like snowflakes in the fullness of the summer sun.
How poetic. Thanks for that thought. Here are some references for your consideration: The Jesus Puzzle. Did Christianity Begin with a Mythical Christ? Challenging the Existence of an Historical Jesus-, by Earl J. Doherty https://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0968601405 "… The epistle to the Hebrews is anonymous. Of those under the names of Peter, James, John and Jude, none today are judged to be authentic. That is, they were not written by those legendary followers of Jesus. These epistles too may originally have been anonymous, or had their original ascriptions dropped; new names were added, possibly at the time the epistles were collected and a canon was being formed …" — The Christ Conspiracy: The Greatest Story Ever Sold-, by Acharaya S http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0932813747 http://www.truthbeknown.com/christcon.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ3.htm http://www.truthbeknown.com/christ4.htm "… In reality, like Jesus, the famous biblical disciples are recorded nowhere in the works of any historian of their time. The only source of the disciples/apostles is in Christian literature, in which the stories of their ‘lives’ are in fact highly apocryphal, allegorical and, therefore, inadequate as ‘history’ or ‘biography’. … The disciple, apostle and saint Peter, ‘the Rock’ to whom so much of the Christian religion is entrusted, is easily revealed to be a mythological character and old motif …" The Book Your Church Doesn’t Want You to Read, by Tim C. Leedom (Editor) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0939040158 "Consider this book as a kind of consumer protection guide to religion, a big step forward toward religious literacy. Readers will explore myths, origins, fundamentalism, television ministries, the identical stories of Stellar/Pagan/ Christian beliefs, unfounded doctrines, child abuse, the Year 2000, and women’s rights. It’s entertaining and readable, with a sense of humor reflecting the absurdities of fundamental religion — while being inoffensive." — Who Wrote the New Testament? The Making of Christian Myth, by Burton L. Mack http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060655186 "I am very selective about books I choose to buy and display; I prefer those that can really make a difference or illustrate a method or a new perspective. Mack’s book does an excellent job of debunking and explaining the Christian myth and deserves widespread reading. If superstition and myth can be recognized and understood as such, society will be strengthened and enriched. It is like the Emperor’s New Clothes – someone has pointed at the Emperor and written an accessible and enlightening book on the subject." — One Jesus, Many Christs : How Jesus Inspired Not One True Christianity, but Many : The Truth About Christian Origins, by Gregory J. Riley http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060667990 "Riley argues that Jesus had a lot in common with familiar figures like Hercules and Achilles. The classical heroes claimed a mix of divine-human parentage, usually with a virgin human mother and a god for a father; they possessed some remarkable or even miraculous skill; they had divine enemies and were hated by powerful humans; they died, often young and violently, as martyrs for a principle; and their deaths powerfully transformed other people’s lives through emulation. Jesus fits the bill perfectly, Riley argues, because the Gospel writers had obtained a classical education, which meant that they were thoroughly steeped in heroic lore. Early converts readily embraced Christianity’s message, despite tremendous penalty from a hostile Roman government, because it captured the heroic formula that peasants had heard recited and then memorized. The second half of the book drives home this point about the source of Christianity’s popularity. Riley demonstrates that it certainly wasn’t doctrine that attracted the masses, since the earliest apostles couldn’t agree on the most basic tenets of the faith. Dozens of sects arose in different cities, all claiming to be the religion of the risen Christ (though whether he had risen in spirit or body was itself a subject of heated debate). What they could agree on was that Jesus was a hero and that they, as martyrs for the faith, could become heroes themselves. Such faithfulness constituted the religion of Christ into the fourth century, which witnessed the conversion of Constantine and the great creedal controversies." — The Case Against Christianity, by Michael Martin http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1566390818 "Logical examination of Christianity by a professional philosopher – This book is logically thorough and destroys Christianity on all important evidential and rational grounds, although I doubt that any whose faith has been sufficient thus far will be led to deconvert. It will however expose them to the fact that they have no rational grounds for their belief." — Pagan and Christian Creeds: Their Origin and Meaning, by Edward Carpenter, preface by Paul Tice http://shop.barnesandnoble.com/booksearch/isbnInquiry.asp?isbn=158509… " A very level-headed approach, doesn’t go after Christianity to attack it, merely compares and contrasts it with the Pagan world and explores similarities and hidden meanings still present in the religion today. Incredible implications." — Why Christianity Must Change or Die : A Bishop Speaks to Believers in Exile, by John Shelby Spong, Richard Dominick http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675365 "Spong refers to himself as a believer in exile. He believes the world into which Christianity was born was limited and provincial, particularly when viewed from the perspective of the progress in knowledge and technology made over the past two millennia. This makes any ideas or beliefs formulated in 1st-century Judea totally inadequate to our progressive minds and lives today. So Spong is in exile until Christianity is re-formed to discard all of the outdated and, according to Spong, false tenets of Christianity." — Liberating the Gospels : Reading the Bible With Jewish Eyes : Freeing Jesus from 2,000 Years of Misunderstanding, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675578 "The Bible has, of course, been read with Jewish eyes from the moment it was written: it is a Jewish book. But Liberating the Gospels is a Christian book; and Spong, bishop of the Episcopal diocese of Newark, New Jersey, urges his Christian audience to remember that the book they call the New Testament was written almost entirely by Jewish authors for an audience that was initially almost entirely Jewish, an audience to whom it would not have occurred to think of the Bible (the ‘Law’ and the ‘Prophets’ ) as anything but Jewish…" — Resurrection : Myth or Reality? : A Bishop’s Search for the Origins of Christianity, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060674296 The Episcopal bishop of Newark, New Jersey, offers a controversial view of the key element in Christianity–the resurrection of Jesus. Spong suggests that Christians have forgotten that the New Testament frequently makes use of Midrash, a genre in which different biblical motifs are interwoven in order to speak of things that transcend human categories. Thus the story of Joshua’s parting of the sea means that he was a second Moses, and the opening of the heavens at Jesus’ baptism tells us that Jesus is the true Moses. Spong argues that since Jesus’ resurrection is divine, it is beyond the realm of history, and the stories surrounding it are Midrash. The question we need to ask, then, is not whether these stories are literally true, but what experience they describe." — Born of a Woman : A Bishop Rethinks the Birth of Jesus, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675233 "John Shelby Spong, best-selling author and Episcopal bishop of Newark, NJ, challenges the doctrine of the virgin birth, tracing its development in the early Christian church and revealing its legacy in our contemporary attitudes toward women and female sexuality. Synopsis: Now in paperback from the best-selling author of Living in Sin? comes a carefully researched, bold, and persuasive argument that ‘the virgin of a literal Bible, the virgin of annunciation, Bethlehem, and the manger, corrupted by the years of an overlaid male theology, will have to go’." — Rescuing the Bible from Fundamentalism : A Bishop Rethinks the Meaning of Scripture, by John Shelby Spong http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0060675187 "Now in paperback, the provocative national bestseller that issues a daring call for contemporary understanding of scripture. Outspoken and controversial, Bishop Spong brilliantly reclaims the Bible from the narrow-minded literalism that has been used to justify slavery, ban textbooks, deny the rights of gays and lesbians, subordinate women, and justify war and revenge." — The Christ Myth (Westminster College-Oxford Classics in the Study of Religion), by Arthur Drews, C. Deslisle Burns (Translator), C. Delisle Burns (Translator) http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/1573921904 "Drawing on the late-eighteenth-century French philosophies and the more contemporary studies of Sir James Frazer and other cultural anthropologists, Drews argues that no basis exists for seeking a historical figure behind the Christ myth. Indeed, if anyone may be called the ‘great personality’ of Christianity, that person is Paul, who gave it the strength to conquer rival religions. Through a comparative study of ancient religions, Drews … read more »
Response:
So, christianity and every other faith has flaws. Go figure. Humans created ‘em so how unflawed could they be? Now, if god had created any of these faiths, don’t yuh think, just maybe, god could’ve come up with an unflawed faith? Maybe? Don’t yuh think, being omnipotent and all, the all-seeing, all-knowing, master of the universe, THE CREATOR of it all, could’ve come close to an unflawed faith, or no god forbid, could’ve actually created an unflawed faith? Nah, that’d be too easy. After all, an unflawed faith would be very difficult to refute or deny and we humans can’t have that, now can we? Nah, we need that "choice" thing so flawed faith, with holes you could drive THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE through are an obvious prerequisite for belief in the silent and invisible CREATOR of the flaws. — And if you don’t buy in to the flawed faith deal, oblivion or eternal hellfire is your reward? — Oh man, get real, why don’t yuh? — Face it, we don’t know where we came from, we don’t know who we are, and we don’t know where we’re going. — We’re tryin’ to find out. We’re curious, but we just don’t know and inventin’ gods and following flawed faiths of ancient and clueless humans ain’t gonna get you there, no way, no how. — Know no god and know the truth. — Peace, love, live long (forever, if science can pull it off) and prosper but don’t, whatever you do, hurt anyone if you can keep from doing so without endangering your own life or the lives of those you cherish. — Drop your faith. You and your children will love you for it. If not today, tomorrow and forever (maybe, hopefully, as no god is my judge). Dan Fake, FREELOVER #1, who cares deeply about truth, freedom, and maxing out this one and only experience we all know and share on this earth, at this time, in this life. FREELOVER? Freethinking Realist Exploring Expressive Liberty, Openness, Verity, Enlightenment, & Rationality (also, pro-love, free from state and church authorities)
Response: